Mayes County, Oklahoma • December 2025

Animal Cruelty Exposed

A documented case of animal abuse caught on home surveillance video. This page exists to spread awareness and ensure this crime is not forgotten.

Victim Coco (French Bulldog)

Status Suspect in custody

Bond $100,000

What Happened

Timeline of Events

Prior to December 2025

Warning Signs Emerge

The victim's owner, Jenna Clark, began noticing that her French Bulldog Coco would hide from Metcalf whenever he was around. She observed injuries on Coco including a bruised eye, a burn on his private area, and a collar that appeared too tight.

December 2025

Fatal Incident Captured on Video

Home surveillance video captured Metcalf stomping on the dog's neck, grabbing it by the neck, and hitting it repeatedly after the dog had an accident on the couch. Coco later fell asleep in Clark's arms one night, and when she woke up, the puppy was gone.

2 Days After Disappearance

Deceptive Search

Metcalf helped Clark search the neighborhood and pass out flyers for two days while Coco was missing—despite knowing the dog's fate. Clark believed her puppy had simply gone missing.

Video Discovery

Truth Revealed

After reviewing her security footage, Clark contacted the Mayes County Sheriff's Office. The evidence was undeniable.

December 11, 2025

Arrest & Confession

Metcalf confessed to the crime and led deputies to a nearby field where Coco's body was found. He was booked into Mayes County Jail on animal cruelty charges with a $100,000 bond.

Case Details

The Evidence

Video Evidence

Home surveillance video from inside the victim's residence captured the abuse on camera. The footage shows Metcalf stomping on the dog's neck, grabbing it by the neck, and hitting it repeatedly. This evidence was key to the arrest.

Confession

According to the Mayes County Sheriff's Office, Metcalf confessed to the crime. He admitted to hitting the dog after it had an accident on the couch and subsequently led deputies to the location where he had disposed of Coco's body.

Prior Injuries

Before the fatal incident, the owner had observed multiple signs of abuse: a bruised eye, a burn on the dog's private area, and a collar that appeared too tight. The dog would also hide from Metcalf whenever he was present.

Body Recovery

After his arrest, Metcalf led deputies to a nearby field where Coco's body was discovered. The owner has stated that seeing her puppy in that field was overwhelming and something she will never forget.

Learn to Recognize

Warning Signs of Animal Abuse

The owner is sharing this story in hopes that others recognize the warning signs of abuse before it's too late. If you notice these signs, take action immediately.

🚨 Animal hides or cowers from a specific person—this indicates fear and past negative experiences.

🚨 Unexplained injuries appearing on your pet, including bruises, burns, or wounds.

🚨 Behavioral changes when a certain person is present—anxiety, trembling, or unusual quietness.

🚨 Signs of restraint injuries such as marks from too-tight collars or bindings.

🚨 Trust your instincts—if something feels wrong about how someone interacts with your pet, investigate immediately.

Oklahoma Law

Legal Consequences

Animal Cruelty in Oklahoma

Animal cruelty is classified as a felony in the state of Oklahoma. The law takes these crimes seriously and provides for significant penalties.

Conviction can result in imprisonment in the county jail for up to one year, or a prison sentence of up to five years at the court's discretion. Additionally, fines of up to $5,000 may be assessed.

Max Years Prison

$5K

Max Fine

$100K

Bond Set

📝 Official Petition

Demand Maximum Penalty

Join thousands calling on District Attorney Matt Ballard to seek the maximum sentence for this act of animal cruelty. Your signature matters.

Signatures

10,000

Goal

0 2,500 5,000 7,500 10,000

We Demand

01 Maximum prison sentence of 5 years under Oklahoma Statute 21 § 1685
02 Maximum fine of $5,000 to be assessed
03 No plea deals that reduce charges or sentencing
04 Lifetime ban on pet ownership
05 Mandatory psychological evaluation and treatment

This Petition Will Be Delivered To:

Matt Ballard

District Attorney, District 12
Mayes County, Oklahoma

Sign the Petition

✓ Thank you! Your signature has been recorded.

✕ Something went wrong. Please try again.

First Name *

Last Name *

Email Address *

City *

State *

Zip Code

I am an Oklahoma resident

Personal Comment (Optional)

I understand my name may be included when this petition is delivered to the District Attorney's office *

🔒 Your email will not be shared publicly. Only your name and city will appear on the petition.

Recent Signatures

Be the first to sign!

Your signature matters

🕯️ In Loving Memory

Remembering Coco

A beloved French Bulldog who brought joy, love, and countless precious moments to those who knew him. These memories live on.

"Until one has loved an animal, a part of one's soul remains unawakened."

— Anatole France